Twenty returning contestants compete in a Heroes vs. Villains-type thing.
Contestants[]
| Contestant | Original Tribe | Merged Tribe | Finish | Total Votes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Erik Reichenbach 28, Santa Clarita, CA Micronesia & Caramoan |
Heroes | 1st Voted Out Day 3 |
5 | |
| Shane Powers 28, Los Angeles, CA Panama |
Villains | 2nd Voted Out Day 5 |
4 | |
| Yau-Man Chan 60, Martinez, CA Fiji & Micronesia |
Heroes | 3rd Voted Out Day 7 |
12 | |
| Brandon Hantz 22, Katy, TX South Pacific & Caramoan |
Villains | 4th Voted Out Day 7 |
5 | |
| NaOnka Mixon 29, Long Beach, CA Nicaragua |
Villains | 5th Voted Out Day 10 |
6 | |
| Christine Shields Markoski 40, Merrick, NY South Pacific |
Heroes | 6th Voted Out Day 13 |
7 | |
| Natalie Bolton 37, Los Angeles, CA Micronesia |
Villains | 7th Voted Out Day 16 |
11 | |
| Ashley Underwood 28, Benton, ME Redemption Island |
Heroes | 8th Voted Out Day 19 |
4 | |
| Oscar "Ozzy" Lusth 31, Venice, CA Cook Islands, Micronesia, & South Pacific |
Heroes | 9th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 22 |
5 | |
| Peter "Pete" Yurkowski 25, Homdel, NJ Philippines |
Villains | 10th Voted Out 2nd Jury Member Day 26 |
4 | |
| Shamar Thomas 28, Brooklyn, NY Caramoan |
Villains | Muc Kcuf | 11th Voted Out 3rd Jury Member Day 28 |
12 |
| Sandra Diaz-Twine 38, Fayetteville, NC Pearl Islands & Heroes vs. Villains |
Villains | 12th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 31 |
5 | |
| Malcolm Freberg 26, Hermosa Beach, CA Philippines & Caramoan |
Heroes | 13th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 33 |
15 | |
| Todd Herzog 28, Pleasant Grove, UT China |
Villains | 14th Voted Out 6th Jury Member Day 33 |
8 | |
| Jud "Fabio" Birza 23, Venice, CA Nicaragua |
Heroes | 15th Voted Out 7th Jury Member Day 36 |
5 | |
| Peih-Gee Law 34, Malibu, CA China |
Heroes | 16th Voted Out 8th Jury Member Day 38 |
8 | |
| Andrea Boehlke 24, New York, NY Redemption Island & Caramoan |
Villains | 17th Voted Out 9th Jury Member Day 38 |
10 | |
| Holly Hoffman 46, Eureka, SD Nicaragua |
Heroes | 2nd Runner-Up | 1 | |
| Corinne Kaplan 34, Los Angeles, CA Gabon & Caramoan |
Villains | Runner-Up | 0 | |
| Sabrina Thompson 34, Brooklyn,NY One World |
Heroes | Sole Survivor | 0 |
Voting History[]
| Original Tribes | Merged Tribe | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Episode # | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | |||
| Eliminated: | Erik 5/10 votes |
Shane 4/10 votes |
Yau-Man 8/9 votes |
Brandon 5/9 votes |
NaOnka 6/8 votes |
Christine 5/8 votes |
Natalie 4/7 votes |
Ashley 4/7 votes |
Ozzy 5/6 votes |
Pete 4/6 votes |
Shamar 6/10 votes |
Sandra 5/9 votes |
Malcolm 7/8 votes |
Todd 6/7 votes |
Fabio 5/6 votes |
Peih-Gee 4/5 votes |
Andrea 3/4 votes |
| Voter | Vote | ||||||||||||||||
| Sabrina | Erik | Yau-Man | Christine | Ashley | Ozzy | Shamar | Sandra | Malcolm | Todd | Fabio | Peih-Gee | Andrea | |||||
| Corinne | Shane | Natalie | NaOnka | Shamar | Pete | Shamar | Sandra | Malcolm | Todd | Fabio | Peih-Gee | Andrea | |||||
| Holly | Erik | Yau-Man | Malcolm | Peih-Gee | Ozzy | Shamar | Sandra | Todd | Todd | Fabio | Peih-Gee | Andrea | |||||
| Andrea | Shane | Natalie | NaOnka | Shamar | Pete | Malcolm | Sandra | Malcolm | Todd | Fabio | Peih-Gee | Holly | |||||
| Peih-Gee | Erik | Yau-Man | Christine | Ashley | Ozzy | Malcolm | Andrea | Malcolm | Todd | Fabio | Andrea | ||||||
| Fabio | Yau-Man | Yau-Man | Christine | Ashley | Ozzy | Shamar | Andrea | Malcolm | Todd | Andrea | |||||||
| Todd | Shamar | Brandon | NaOnka | Natalie | Pete | Malcolm | Sandra | Malcolm | Peih-Gee | ||||||||
| Malcolm | Yau-Man | Yau-Man | Christine | Ashley | Ozzy | Shamar | Andrea | Malcolm | |||||||||
| Sandra | Shane | Brandon | NaOnka | Natalie | Pete | Shamar | Andrea | ||||||||||
| Shamar | Natalie | Natalie | Andrea | Natalie | Andrea | Malcolm | |||||||||||
| Pete | Shamar | Brandon | NaOnka | Natalie | Shamar | ||||||||||||
| Ozzy | Yau-Man | Yau-Man | Christine | Peih-Gee | Malcolm | ||||||||||||
| Ashley | Erik | Yau-Man | Malcolm | Peih-Gee | |||||||||||||
| Natalie | Shamar | Brandon | NaOnka | Todd | |||||||||||||
| Christine | Erik | Yau-Man | Malcolm | ||||||||||||||
| NaOnka | Natalie | Brandon | Andrea | ||||||||||||||
| Brandon | Shane | Natalie | |||||||||||||||
| Yau-Man | Christine | Christine | |||||||||||||||
| Shane | Natalie | ||||||||||||||||
| Erik | Yau-Man | ||||||||||||||||
| Jury Vote | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Finalist: | Holly 1/9 votes |
Corinne 2/9 votes |
Sabrina 6/9 votes |
| Juror | Vote | ||
| Andrea | Corinne | ||
| Peih-Gee | Holly | ||
| Fabio | Sabrina | ||
| Todd | Sabrina | ||
| Malcolm | Sabrina | ||
| Sandra | Sabrina | ||
| Shamar | Sabrina | ||
| Pete | Sabrina | ||
| Ozzy | Corinne | ||